Dr. Bill's
CE Class Notes
New
Hope CE, November 2005
INTRO
Every day at New Hope we talk and chat with people
who are overwhelmed by someone else's problems. They say things
like:
- "I'm worried
about my husband's drinking."
- "My girlfriend
is depressed again and nothing I say seems to help."
- "I keep
getting into relationships with abusive men!"
- "If my
son cared about me he'd stop ____________."
- "I can't
seem to please anybody in my life."
They're only
happy if the person they're focused on is happy. They try so hard
to please this person. They're consumed with helping their loved
one who may have an addiction, be depressed, or just have lots
of problems. Their identity is wrapped up in someone else's body!
They've become "Co-Dependent" - depended upon their relationship
with a dysfunctional person.
This topic
hits home! Many of us as counselors and care-givers have co-dependency
issues. We have such caring hearts that we can't say no to needy
people or stray cats! We're so sensitive that we feel bad if we
hurt a bug or if a stranger says an unkind word. Our sympathy
for others overrides our boundaries and gets us into trouble.
Co-dependency
is a wild roller coaster of a ride! You lose the freedom and joy
of being yourself. You miss your other friends and family. Your
relationship with God suffers.
How do we
break out of these crazy relationships? How do we establish healthy
boundaries with the people we love and those we want to help?
How do we as New Hope Counselors help co-depended callers/chatters?
Sometimes
we just need to laugh at ourselves!
You're codependent
for sure if, when you die, someone else's life flashes in front
of your eyes.
You're codependent
for sure when you get kicked off jury duty for insisting that
you're the guilty one.
You're codependent
for sure when you wake up in the morning and say to your mate:
"Good morning, how am I?
Did you hear
about the codependent who flunked geography? He couldn't distinguish
any boundaries.
Q. Why did
the codependent cross the road? A. To help the chicken make a
decision.
Q. What does
a codependent have in common with God? A. They both have a plan
for your life.
How do 2 co-dependents
do lunch?
They get in
their car, then drive around for a half hour saying: "What do
You want?"
"Oh, Whatever
You want."
"But what
do You feel like today?"
"Whatever
You decide will be great"
How can you
tell you're at an Alanon meeting?
Someone spills
their coffee and everyone gets up to clean it up.
You know that
pastors and other helpers like us often struggle with co-dependency.
Let me tell you a story about that. There was a cowboy who went to church one Sunday. When he entered, he saw that he and the preacher
were the only ones present. The preacher asked the cowboy if he
wanted him to go ahead and preach.
The cowboy
said, "I'm not too smart, but if I went to feed my cattle and
only one showed up, I'd feed him." So the minister began his sermon.
One hour passed,
then two hours, then two-and-a-half hours. The preacher finally
finished and came down to ask the cowboy how he liked the sermon.
The cowboy answered slowly, "Well, I'm not very smart, but if
I went to feed my cattle and only one showed up, I sure wouldn't
feed him all the hay."
WHAT IS
CO-DEPENDENCY?
About 20 years
ago when I was going through graduate school co-dependency was
being identified as a problem from studies of alcoholic and chemically
addicted families. It was discovered that addicts typically had
a responsible, caring person in their life who unintentionally
"enabled" them to continue in their destructive behavior. The
enablers were found to be co-dependent in that they were "addicted"
to their relationship with the alcoholic or drug addict.
Since then
understanding of co-dependency has broadened to include an addiction
to being in relationship with people who have other emotional
problems. The crucial aspects are that co-dependents are:
1. Compulsively
involved in dysfunctional relationships that don't meet their
needs (They "need" to help people with problems to feel better.)
2. Enmeshed
with other people so that their personal identity (feelings, needs,
values, opinions) are crowded out by others identity, problems,
or needs. These boundary problems make their relationships stressful
if not chaotic and painful. Their expression of themselves and
their growth and life mission are stunted or completely sidetracked.
3. Trying
to control their painful internal feelings by controlling
people and situations on the outside. This provides temporary
relief but leaves the underlying problems unresolved.
If you met
a co-dependent person what would he or she look like? You may
have one in your family. Probably at least one of your friends
is co-dependent. I am sure that you talk to a co-dependent person
on almost every New Hope shift. Perhaps the co-dependent person
in your life is the face looking back at you in the mirror!
I read that
some studies show 50-80% of professional counselors have not addressed
their own co-dependence. That's a scary thought!
Let's not
make that mistake! You know we help other people out of who we
are. So learning about ourselves and growing psychologically and
spiritually is the best thing we can do to be more compassionate
and helpful.
So I want
to give you a few moments to take this Co-Dependency Survey. After
you take the survey for yourself you might think about someone
you know and how he or she would answer these questions.
Co-Dependency
Survey
Flynn:
a 35-year old woman from New Zealand, story from "A Fine Kettle
of Fish"
"I left my
marriage with Sean because I felt crushed, suffocated, and trapped
- by HIS needs, HIS feelings, HIS opinions. We were both strong
personalities, but somehow, through the course of having babies,
moving cities, and adjusting to parenthood, I had made his needs
paramount.
It happened
so gradually over the years that I had to go to counseling before
I could even imagine being strong enough to leave this dominating
man.
Finally I
left Sean. I felt SO empowered, SO independent. I was sure my
marriage had failed because of his inability to compromise and
his sometimes obnoxious personality.
After a year
along came Chris. He seemed the opposite of Sean in every way:
quiet, unassuming, caring, great with the kids, everybody's friend.
We moved in together but after two years of living together, I
realized that, yet again, I was more worried about HIS thoughts
and reactions than my own! I was judging how to be on the basis
of how HE was! And I never went out with my girlfriends; I gave
up everything for him.
So no more
excuses. I had to look at myself - my own patterns and responses."
Where did
Flynn's co-dependency cause her problems? She lost her self in
the men she was with; her boundaries weren't defined or maintained.
And she blamed the problems in her marriage on her husband. But
after her second relationship also failed she looked in the mirror
and saw her co-dependency that she needed help with - that's the
beginning of recovery.
Male pastor:
story from National Association of Christian Recovery
I was raised
in a family with a rage-aholic mother and a workaholic father.
Dad was gone all the time. Our family owned a dairy farm and a
potato farm and he worked seven days a week.
When I got
off the bus from school it didn't matter what kind of day it had
been. It didn't matter if I had been beaten up on the playground.
It didn't matter if I had done well on a test. The only thing
that mattered was where is Mom and how long will it be before
she explodes in rage. So I developed huge emotional antenna that
would pick up on what was happening emotionally in the house.
I became so aware of how she felt and I did everything I could
to please her so she wouldn't explode in rage.
When I left
home I did the same things with other people. And I became a rescuer.
When people got in trouble they knew they could call me. My friends
could get drunk and wreck their cars and they knew they could
call me to come pick them up and help them out. I was always available
for everybody.
The other
thing is that I became a good manipulator. Once I knew how other
people were feeling I could play that and get them to do what
I wanted them to do. I loved to control people. But I was clueless
about what I wanted and needed.
When I got
saved I had a powerful experience with God. I knew God loved me.
I knew that Jesus had died for me. I put my faith in God but I
didn't really change - except keeping all the rules. I quit smoking
and drinking and I went to church five times a week. Emotionally
I was still the same old self. My "old man" had put on a Christian
suit. I was accepted but I wasn't really me.
I became a
pastor but in time I burned out. It wasn't until I went into depression
that I got real help. I began to realize that when the Bible talks
about denial of self and putting to death the old self that was
not another heavy burden on a to-do-list. It means that God doesn't
want me to be co-dependent anymore. It means that finding a different
way of being in the world then all the destructive things I learned
in my dysfunctional family.
Where did
this pastor's co-dependency lead to burn out? He was giving and
helping others and doing so in his own strength, not God's, and
under the compulsion of doing what he "should" do. And he wasn't
admitting his own needs and asking for the care and help he needed.
WHAT CAUSES
CO-DEPENDENCY?
Children who
grow up under the care of a parent who is an addict, abusive,
neglectful, or mentally ill are likely to become co-dependent.
Dysfunctional family systems like these operate with harmful rules:
- Don't feel,
don't talk about your feelings, and don't trust anyone.
- In conflict
or with sensitive issues don't talk to the person directly -
if you have to talk about it go through a third party. (Triangulation)
- Be strong,
good, right, perfect. (You can't be a needy, playful child.)
- Don't be
selfish; take care of other people.
- Do as I
say, not as I do.
"The
Cycle of Co-Dependency" Diagram
Love Hunger
(God Vacuum) -> Denial (of needs, sins, and hurts) -> Co-dependent
relationship (Idolatry) -> Temporary Pain Relief -> Negative
Consequences (mistreatment, rejection, conflict, emotional roller
coaster, burn out, depression, anxiety) -> Cycle Repeats
CO-DEPENDENCY
IS NOT HELPFUL!
Co-dependents
think they're being helpful and loving in their relationship with
the addict or dysfunctional person. But unwittingly they "enable"
this person to be irresponsible by shielding them from the negative
consequences of their behavior. People who are acting unwisely
need to experience the natural negative consequences of their
behavior in order to learn from it and be motivated to change!
Here are some examples of how enabling shields addicts/dysfunctional
people from God's laws of reaping the consequences of what they've
sown (Galatians 6:7-8):
- Care-taking
- doing for the dependent person what he/she should do for self
(e.g., in parenting)
- Making
excuses for their irresponsibility (e.g., covering up with family,
friends, work, school, legal authorities)
- Baling
the person out of trouble (e.g., with money)
- Keeping
secrets or avoiding talking about problems to keep peace
- Blaming
others for the dependent person's problems
- Victimizing
the addict ("He/she can't help it because of wounds, past problems,
stress.")
- Making
idle threats (about not helping next time, leaving, etc)
GETTING
FREE OF TOXIC FAITH THAT SUPPORTS CO-DEPENDENCY
For many people
co-dependency seems like a Christian way to function. We tend
to think:
- It's selfish
to think of my own needs
- We're supposed
to be servants and put others first
- After all,
Jesus taught us to deny ourselves
- It's unloving
to hurt someone's feelings!
- It's unloving
to say no to someone who is hurting or needs help!
These are
just a few points of confusion. Let's look briefly at one, turning
to God's Word for clarity:
Being selfish
We think it's
selfish to ask for what we need. It is - but in a good sense.
We have to start here and God knows this. Jesus taught us repeatedly
to ask God for what we need:
"Keep on asking,
and you will be given what you ask for. Keep on looking, and you
will find. Keep on knocking, and the door will be opened. Your
heavenly Father [will] give good gifts to those who ask him" (Matthew
7:7, 11b, NLT). Another time he said, "You can go directly to
the Father and ask him, and he will grant your request because
you use my name. and you will receive, and you will have abundant
joy" (John 16:23b-24, NLT).
The truth
is that it's more selfish not to ask for what you need
because if you don't then the people who love you will be burdened
to try to figure it out in order to care for you. Furthermore,
it's simply inhuman and impossible to live without having needs
so if you try to do so you'll just be suppressing or repressing
them and they'll unconsciously and indirectly affect your behavior
in ways that confuse, burden, manipulate, or violate others. That's
the kind of selfishness that's a problem!
Putting
others needs first
The way of
love is to put others first. But you have to grow into this. The
only way to do this well is to operate out of being cared for
yourself. For instance, if you're flying on an airplane with a
small child they always tell you that if there's an emergency
and the oxygen masks drop down put your own oxygen mask on first
and then put your child's on.
Often the
Bible speaks of this as loving others out of the "overflow" of
God's love to you. For instance in Psalm 23:5b (NIV) David rejoices,
"My cup overflows."
When Jesus
teaches us the Greatest Commandment, "Love the Lord your God.
Love your neighbor as yourself" (Mark 12:29-31), he is teaching
us a deep truth. If you really love God with your whole self then
you'll show it by loving others. Why? Because God is love. You're
loving the one who loves you perfectly and his love is meant to
be shared. You'll be so blessed by his love for you and knowing
that you are loveable and you'll want others to have this same
blessing.
The Bible
teaches us to live in mutual, "one another" love. My needs matter
as much as yours and your needs matter as much as mine. We're
of equal value. Repeatedly, we're told to "love one another."
If you don't let me love you (because you think you should put
others needs first) then you cheat me out of the blessing and
honor of giving to you! So Paul teaches us to consider our own
interests and other's interests:
"Each
of you should look not only to your own interests, but also to
the interests of others" (Philippians 2:4, NIV).
Recovery
from Co-Dependency Bible Verses
Visit my personal
website, http://www.christiansoulcare.com/, for a listing of Scripture
passages and the insights they teach to help with overcoming co-dependency
issues.
Self-denial
This is one
of the most important and yet least understood teachings in the
Bible. It's taught all over the Scriptures, including by Jesus:
"Then [Jesus]
said to them all: 'If anyone would come after me, he must deny
himself and take up his cross daily and follow me. For whoever
wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life
for me will save it. What good is it for a man to gain the whole
world, and yet lose or forfeit his very self?'" (Luke 9:23-25,
NIV).
What most
people don't understand is that you must have a good self-identity
in order to deny it: set it aside, lose it to love others. Jesus
himself had a very strong sense of self; he was aware of and often
acted in consideration of his feelings, needs, values, and human
limitations.
Sometimes
love hurts another's feelings
In our culture
we are really messed up when it comes to feelings. On one hand
we have problems with denying legitimate feelings which causes
us many problems like detachment in relationships, projection
of issues onto other people, depression, anxiety, and many other
things. On the other hand, we totally glorify feelings. We think
that we shouldn't do anything unless we feel like it. It seems
inauthentic to do something unless you feel like doing it. We
even define what is right but what feels right. And we'll do almost
anything to feel good: drink, lust, eat, lose our temper, gossip,
go shopping. We can hardly imagine depriving ourselves something
we want and sill feeling good.
One aspect
of how messed up we are with feelings is that we think it's always
bad to hurt someone's feelings. Of course, we should go around
trying to hurt other people's feelings! But there are times where
we must speak the truth or set a limit even it someone doesn't
feel good for others.
Many of the
things that Jesus said and did hurt other people's feelings -
especially the Pharisees, but other people too. How do you think
the woman caught in adultery felt when Jesus said, "Go and sin
no more"? Or the rich young ruler when Jesus told him to sell
everything and give the money to the poor? Or Peter when Jesus
replied to Peter's plea that Jesus not go to the cross by saying,
"Get behind me Satan!"? Or his own mother when at 12 years old
he told her that his Father's business was more important to him
than his relationship to her?
When I read
the Bible the Lord often hurts my feelings. As just one example,
recently in my Scripture meditation I came across Hebrews 12:7
(NIV):
"Endure hardship
as discipline; God is treating you as sons."
This is a
verse that some years ago the Lord challenged me to live by. Do
you think this makes me feel good? Of course not! When disappointments
or bad things happen in my life I don't like to think that God
allowed them and wants to use them to train me. I'd rather he
just make the problem go away! However, as I accept painful situations
under God's sovereignty other feelings develop for me - good feelings
of love, joy, and peace. (Of course, the Fruit of the Spirit are
more than feelings, their godly characteristics, but a component
of them is feeling, wonderful feelings!)
Sometimes
love says no
Jesus taught
us that sometimes we need to say no to people. Of course, we must
say no to sinful and destructive behavior. And we must say no
when we have to admit our limitation:
"Simply let
your 'Yes' be 'Yes,' and your 'No,' 'No'; anything beyond this
comes from the evil one" (Matthew 5:37, NIV).
Jesus taught
that the ability to say no was important - even in our relationship
with God! It's called freedom of choice and being able to express
our no is a foundational aspect of a healthy self-identity. And
when you're able to say no then you're also able to say yes!
"[Jesus said].
'Tell me what you think of this story: A man had two sons. He
went up to the first and said, "Son, go out for the day and work
in the vineyard." The son answered, "I don't want to." Later on
he thought better of it and went. The father gave the same command
to the second son. He answered, "Sure, glad to." But he never
went. Which of the two sons did what the father asked?' They said,
'The first.' Jesus said, 'Yes, and I tell you that crooks and
whores are going to precede you into God's kingdom. John came
to you showing you the right road. You turned up your noses at
him, but the crooks and whores believed him. Even when you saw
their changed lives, you didn't care enough to change and believe
him'" (Matthew 21:28-32, MSG).
Jesus demonstrated
this time and again himself. So often we read in the gospels accounts
like this:
"Very early
in the morning, while it was still dark, Jesus got up, left the
house and went off to a solitary place, where he prayed. Simon
and his companions went to look for him, and when they found him,
they exclaimed: 'Everyone is looking for you!' Jesus replied,
'Let us go somewhere else-to the nearby villages-so I can preach
there also. That is why I have come.'" (Mark 1:35-38, NIV).
Jesus said
no. Because of the limitations of his humanity he needed time
alone with the Father. Because of the limitations of his time
on earth he needed to move on to minister to other people.
UNDOING
THE NEGATIVE CYCLE OF CO-DEPENDENCY
Contrast this
positive cycle of Recovery from Co-Dependency with the negative
vicious circle above:
Love Hunger
(God Vacuum) -> Truth (about needs, sins, and hurts) ->
Trust God and Christ's Ambassadors -> Comfort and Learning
-> Empowered to be your SHAPE for God and others
IGNATIAN
MEDITATION EXERCISE
Here's an
experience to help you rely on God through his Word and prayer
for help with any co-dependency issues you may to have. This passage
demonstrates Jesus helping his disciples, who were tired from
ministry, come away with him for rest and then to draw their substance
and strength for ministry from him. It also shows Jesus' generosity
with the crowd, who were more hungry for his words than they were
for food.
This approach
to meditation was developed by St. Ignatius hundreds of years
ago. It's designed for gospel passages and it's still used today
in "The Spiritual Exercises." I introduced Ignatian meditation
at the recent mini-retreat on meditation, "Meeting Jesus in God's
Word," which is available on CD.
Silence
Quietly focus
your conscious awareness on God's loving presence.
Gospel
Read Mark
6:30-44 (NIV). Focus on Jesus and notice details. You may want
to mark the passage with underlines, circles, or notes.
30The
apostles gathered around Jesus and reported to him all they had
done and taught. 31Then, because so many people were
coming and going that they did not even have a chance to eat,
he said to them, "Come with me by yourselves to a quiet place
and get some rest."
32So
they went away by themselves in a boat to a solitary place. 33But
many who saw them leaving recognized them and ran on foot from
all the towns and got there ahead of them. 34When Jesus
landed and saw a large crowd, he had compassion on them, because
they were like sheep without a shepherd. So he began teaching
them many things.
35By
this time it was late in the day, so his disciples came to him.
"This is a remote place," they said, "and it's already very late.
36Send the people away so they can go to the surrounding
countryside and villages and buy themselves something to eat."
37But
he answered, "You give them something to eat." They said to him,
"That would take eight months of a man's wages! Are we to go and
spend that much on bread and give it to them to eat?"
38"How
many loaves do you have?" he asked. "Go and see."When they found
out, they said, "Five-and two fish."
39Then
Jesus directed them to have all the people sit down in groups
on the green grass. 40So they sat down in groups of
hundreds and fifties. 41Taking the five loaves and
the two fish and looking up to heaven, he gave thanks and broke
the loaves. Then he gave them to his disciples to set before the
people. He also divided the two fish among them all. 42They
all ate and were satisfied, 43and the disciples picked
up twelve basketfuls of broken pieces of bread and fish. 44The
number of the men who had eaten was five thousand.
Pick a
place in the story
Stand in the
place of a character you identify with (a disciples who is tired
from ministry; someone in the crowd who is hungry; Jesus who is
teaching, feeding, and thanking God) or just stand next to Jesus
as an observer.
Pray (Petition)
Ask Jesus
for what you need from him now. You may want to journal your prayer
on the back.
Enter the
story
Slowly re-read
the story using all of your senses - see, hear, touch, smell,
and taste what's going on - to re-create the story and imagine
yourself in it.
Listen
Ask God to
show you in pictures or tell you in words what this passage means
for you personally. You may want to write down what God seems
to be showing you.
Pray (Respond)
Thank God
for what he's revealed to you. You may want to journal this prayer
too.
NEW HOPE
COUNSELING ROLE PLAY ON CO-DEPENDENCY
The following
chatter comments are excerpted from an actual New Hope Online
chat room conversation. The counselor responses (in italics) are
my responses as offered live in the class. Let's call the chatter
by the name of Randy. He's about 50 years and lives in a rural
area in one of America's Southern states.
Randy: A few
months ago I came home to find my wife drunk. The neighbors were
over and they had too much to drink too. Some cross words were
said and the next thing I knew, I was at the porch steps getting
cursed out by my wife.
Counselor:
This was traumatic for you Randy.
Randy: Yes,
I was left alone crying. I was so upset so I went for a drive.
Counselor:
It seems you were wounded by your wife's angry words.
Randy: Later
I learned that my wife has been having an affair with a married
man.
Counselor:
Oh my. I imagine your heart is broken by this news of her betrayal.
Randy: The
man she had an affair with has since gotten back with his wife
and my wife says she wants to fix our marriage. Her family members
are all Christians and they've gone to bat for our marriage. So
has our church. In fact, all the churches in about a 100 mile
radius are praying for us.
Counselor:
So you're hopeful that your marriage can be restored.
Randy: And
she's been going to church. But she's terribly confused. She says
she isn't in love with me anymore.
Counselor:
Ouch. That hurts you deep.
Randy: My
nerves are shot, my health is shot, and I don't know what to pray
next. I had my first heart attack at 31 and my doctor said that
the next one is imminent if I don't manage my stress better.
Counselor:
I understand that the tenuousness of your marriage is stressing
your body and leaving you scared for your health.
Randy: I know
it's all in God's time, but this is an emergency! I know it's
not a battle between her and I. It's a battle with God and I against
Satan.
Counselor:
I see that you're trying hard to keep a positive attitude towards
your wife while you cry out for God's help to fight for your marriage.
Randy: She
is my soul mate - the one God chose for me. I love her with all
my heart and I forgive her without any questions asked. She is
my home. I just want to go home with her where I belong.
Counselor:
If only you could have her back.
Randy: I am
doing all I can to try to win her back, but she is still pulling
away like a rabid bull.
Counselor:
It's hard for you to understand Randy, but apparently the harder
you pursue her to get her back the more she rejects you.
Randy: I can't
give up. That would be to tell her that she can have a divorce
and to stop praying for restoration and to quite believing God
for what I've asked.
Counselor:
Acknowledging her freedom to stay in the marriage or not doesn't
mean that you can't keep praying and believing for God's best.
Randy: I need
to be loved and I need it from my wife!
Counselor:
Of course, you want this, but you don't have control over her.
I wonder what else you can do to get your needs met?
Randy: The
one thing that gives me peace or enjoyment now is going to church
Counselor:
Hmm. That does sound good for you. What else can you do for help?
Randy: I guess
the other thing that helps is being able to vent, like talking
to you.
Counselor:
You have been quite honest and courageous in sharing your heart
with me.
Randy: Also
it helps knowing that people are praying for me.
Counselor:
Would you like me to pray for you now?
Randy: Yes,
that'd be great.
Counselor:
Dear Lord, we lift up Randy to you. His heart has been broken
by his wife's affair. He so desperately wants her back. She says
she wants to work on the marriage but she keeps pulling away.
It's so confusing for Randy. His only hope is in you Lord. We
ask you to restore his marriage, to work in his wife's heart so
that she'd be faithful to Randy. And we ask you to comfort and
heal Randy's heart and to work your grace in their relationship
so that they can reconcile. And in the meantime please continue
to help Randy to be encouraged by his church and the prayers and
caring of his friends. Lord it hurts so much when she pulls away
from him so strengthen his boundaries to protect his heart and
to help him to focus on the things that he can do with your help.
In Jesus' name we pray. Amen.
CO-DEPENDENCY
REFERRALS
See also
"Addictions &
Compulsive Behavior"
|